Excerpts from Coronaviruses in the domestic animal kingdomWhat the zoonotic origin of SARS-CoV-2 implies for pets and livestock
April 3, 2020 (published)
By Natalie Slivinski
Since February, four household pets have tested positive for SARS-CoV-2, the coronavirus sweeping the globe: two dogs in Hong Kong, a Pomeranian and a German shepherd; a cat in Belgium; and, most recently, a cat in Hong Kong. All the animals' owners had COVID-19. Although they apparently picked up viral particles shed by their human companions, none of the Hong Kong pets showed signs of illness consistent with COVID-19. The Belgian cat, however, did become sick, showing signs about a week after its owner became ill.
The occurrences raise questions about whether pets could become part of the COVID-19 transmission chain. Veterinarians and other health experts say there is no cause for owners to abandon their animals for fear of catching the disease — if anything, it's the pets who should be kicking us out. There is no evidence that pets can transmit the virus back to people. "I think it's far more likely that they'll get it from the person that's shedding large amounts of virus, rather than the other way around," said Dr. Melissa Kennedy, a virologist at the University of Tennessee College of Veterinary Medicine.
Medical experts say the real threat lies in human-to-human transmission. While some pet species may be able to pick up infections, that doesn't mean they play a role in spreading the virus. Still, research is ongoing, and owners should include their pets when practicing COVID-19 precautions.
In his blog Worms & Germs, Dr. J. Scott Weese, a pathobiologist and internal medicine specialist at the University of Guelph's Ontario Veterinary College, advises: "If you're sick, stay away from animals just like you would other people. If you have COVID-19 and have been around your pets, keep your pets inside and away from other people. While the risk of transmission to or from a pet is low, we don't want an exposed pet tracking this virus out of the household (just like we don't want an infected person doing that)."
The veterinary and research communities remain vigilant. But although domestic animals such as cats and dogs may be infected, viral transmission in household pets is considered unlikely. Based on current evidence, Kennedy believes that dogs are not "epidemiologically important" for COVID-19. That's because there's more to a successful infection than sticking to host cells. And while humans provide a very comfortable environment for SARS-CoV-2, Kennedy said, dogs apparently do not.
'Infected' versus 'infectious'
The dogs that tested positive in Hong Kong were found to have viral RNA in the mouth and nose. When the Hong Kong Agriculture, Fisheries and Conservation Department performed serological tests to measure antibodies against COVID-19 in the blood of the Pomeranian, the final result came back positive, indicating a bona fide infection. However, the dog never showed any clinical signs.
In fact, you can be infected with a virus without feeling sick. When you feel ill, it's the result of the virus replicating to high enough levels to do two things: first, to destroy large numbers of healthy cells; and second, to trigger inflammation that can cause unpleasant symptoms such as fever and coughing. But if the virus can't replicate efficiently, it can't muster enough copies of itself to pose much of a challenge to the body's immune system, which mounts a coordinated attack and clears out the invader before its host notices symptoms.
It seems likely, Kennedy said, that dogs are not a hospitable host for SARS-CoV-2. "The host specificity of a virus is determined, basically, by two factors," she explained: "One, that the cells the virus is infecting have a receptor that it can attach to. And then, once the virus is inside the cell, that cell has to be able to provide everything that the virus needs in order to replicate."
While dogs' cells might have a fitting ACE2 receptor, Kennedy suspects that SARS-CoV-2 isn't happy enough in the canine cellular environment to replicate to high levels. There must also be a large enough dose of virus to breach the frontline defenses of every new host. Without the ability to replicate efficiently, the virus has nowhere to go.
In humans, there's no doubt: Our bodies are like a five-star hotel for SARS-CoV-2. We can transmit the disease even without symptoms, perhaps because our cells are quite permissive to the virus. This effect is amplified in cities, where the high density of people means that a large population is being exposed to particularly high levels of virus.
As for dogs, Kennedy believes they are likely a dead end for SARS-CoV-2 — meaning they can catch the virus but they cannot give it back. While human cells are permissive for some reason, canine cells may not be. "From what we know thus far, the dog is not providing everything that virus needs in order to replicate to significant enough levels to make it important in the spread of the virus," she said. "There may not be enough permissive cells. But that's under investigation now."
The cells of cats and ferrets, however, appear to be more receptive to coronaviruses. Scientists at Harbin Veterinary Research Institute in China, in a study not yet peer reviewed, found that "SARS-CoV-2 replicates poorly in dogs, pigs, chickens and ducks, but efficiently in ferrets and cats. We found that the virus transmits in cats via respiratory droplets."
The finding on cats and ferrets is consistent with the SARS virus from 2002. For that reason, Weese, who is a zoonotic disease expert at Ontario Veterinary College, anticipated some weeks ago that cats and ferrets might become infected by the virus that causes COVID-19. "With the original SARS virus, cats ... were able to grow enough virus to pass it on to another cat," he said.
Weese was therefore unsurprised by the news about the Belgian cat, which had both a positive test result and clinical signs. According to an article in The Brussels Times, the cat had diarrhea, vomiting and difficulty breathing. Researchers found virus in the cat's feces, the newspaper reported. The cat in Hong Kong, which has not shown any signs of the disease, also had virus in its rectal samples, as well as in its mouth and nose, according to the government statement.
Ferrets, too, have been found to have ACE2 receptors and are permissive to a number of viruses that infect humans, including some types of bird flu and seasonal flu, according to Kennedy. Early studies have shown that SARS-CoV-2 replicates well in ferret cells. However, Weese believes their transmission risks are low, at least from an epidemiological standpoint.
"If you put a cat and a ferret in front of me and ask me which one I want to get in close contact with, I'd pick the cat, because ferrets are high risk at that one-on-one level," he said. "But for me, cats are still a bigger concern because there are a lot more cats than ferrets."
While the susceptibility of ferrets may be worrisome for ferret owners, it could be a boon for COVID-19 research. According to the New York Times, scientists at the University of Pittsburgh recently found that a ferret in their lab developed a high fever after being exposed to SARS-CoV-2. The strong immune response suggests ferrets likely are vulnerable to illness, which makes them a promising animal model for developing a COVID-19 vaccine.
Despite the ferret finding, experts believe the likelihood of catching COVID-19 from a pet ferret or cat is low. Even if transmission to individual owners is theoretically possible, both Weese and Kennedy believe the risk does not translate to large-scale spread.
"An infected cat isn't a big concern in the household, since the person who exposed the cat in the first place is the main risk," Weese wrote last week in his blog. "The virus is being transmitted very effectively person to person, so animals likely play little role, if any, in the grand scheme of things."
Other than the Belgian cat, there are no other reports of domestic animals, including livestock, getting sick with COVID-19. That could change, of course; more animals from households with COVID-19 cases need to be tested to form a clearer picture.
Furthermore, coronaviruses constantly mutate. They are RNA viruses, which, unlike DNA viruses, have no proofreading enzymes that fix mistakes in the course of replicating. Coronaviruses also have unusually large genomes. That leads to a large number of mutations, and such genetic "mistakes" are what drive their evolution. "Those mistakes are purely random," Kennedy explained, "but if they give that virus selective advantage over its comrades, then that mutation will be maintained in the virus population."
If SARS-CoV-2 were to mutate such that the virus became more able to infect and spread, domestic animals could become reservoirs. That would have major implications for a world full of pet and livestock owners. It's also theoretically possible the virus could find a way to spill over from cats or ferrets back into humans. But there's no evidence to date that this is happening.
A call for common sense
Weese is working on testing more animals from COVID-19-positive households. "We're trying to do active surveillance of animals that are in contact with infected people," he said.
If many more positive tests emerge in pets, public-health experts will review the transmission risks. But routinely testing large populations of domestic animals would be impractical and probably not very informative, Weese said: "Testing is useful to use from a research standpoint, but testing your average animal isn't something we want to get done."
His focus is on practical protective measures. For pig farmers, for example, simply exercising caution may effectively prevent transmission. "If you've got COVID and you've got pigs but you don't go near the barn, then we don't have to worry about it," Weese said. "And with farmers, it's actually probably easier [than with pet owners], because a pig farmer realizes that if someone reports a pig being positive, pork prices are going to plummet."
For pet owners, it's about managing animals the same way we manage people, Weese said. This means staying separated from pets if you're sick, as painful as it may be to deny yourself snuggle therapy. It also means including pets in social distancing. If you are under local stay-at-home orders and keeping a distance from others, keep your pet distant from others, too. Even if pets can't get COVID-19, viral particles can get on their mouth, nose, fur or skin and be picked up by the next person who touches them. Think of pets as another surface that can be contaminated, like a countertop or door handle. The overall message, Weese said, is simple: "Just use common sense."
The best defense against transmission by household pets is to keep exposed animals in the home but sometimes this is impossible; for instance, if someone who lives alone needs to be hospitalized. In a blog post Thursday, Weese discusses options for such situations. The best scenario, he writes, is for someone who has recovered from COVID-19 to come into the household to continue caring for the pet. If no one is available, not even a benevolent low-risk neighbor, owners may be able to temporarily house their pet with a shelter or clinic that has the facilities and capacity. Weese's own hospital is positioned to house animals from COVID-19 households. Space is limited, and the option is intended as a last resort. "We're set up to handle those animals," he said, "but our focus is to keep animals in the household or find alternative approaches rather than see them in clinics."
During the COVID-19 epidemic, we have been adjusting our hours in order to help with the prevention of the spread of this terrifying virus. As of now, we are open Monday through Friday 9am-5pm and are closed on weekends until this crisis is over. Things might change on short notice, but we will keep you informed here and in our blog at PeninsulaAveVet.com. We have strict protocols where most of the visit is over the phone and only the patient is allowed in the hospital. We bring in canine patients with our own sanitized 6 foot leash or transfer carriers and medications by always keeping a 6 foot distance plus protective gear on ourselves. We ask that clients let us know if they have COVID-19 or anyone in their household has been exposed to someone who has, or could have symptoms of COVID-19. We are working on keeping our patients healthy while avoiding any spread of COVID-19. Our online pharmacy (http://www.peninsulaavevet.com/pharmacy.html) is the fastest way to get home delivered medications and prescription foods. We have also started offering teleconference appointments for cases where that is possible without an examination of the patient.
Please stay tuned for updates- we place them here to avoid mass emails to clients.
Thank you all for being amazing following the protocols to keep us all safe from COVID-19, Please do not enter the clinic if you are sick or caring for someone sick. We can get your pet from the car and talk over the phone or Facetime. We are limiting one healthy person per visit to the clinic, waiting in the car or outside, keeping our distance, using hand sanitizers and disinfecting throughout the day. We can also mail medications and you can use PENINSULA AVENUE VET CLINIC ONLINE PHARMACY through our website. It is the fastest way to get the medications to you if you do not want to come to the clinic because the order is one step and not involving faxes back and forth.
You may hear in the news about the passing of the 17-year-old Pomeranian dog that was released from quarantine in Hong Kong. THERE IS NO EVIDENCE WHATSOEVER OF DOGS TRANSMITTING COVID-19 TO PEOPLE. This dog was tested negative twice, never showed signs of illness and no antibodies in the blood. It just happened to have sniffed some from the owner's virus into the nasal passages. It is not uncommon for a dog to die suddenly at that age. Those are fairly advanced geriatric years. Unfortunately, the owner declined necropsy and now the cause of death will be speculated. Given no other dogs in the same situation have exhibited signs of Coronavirus, please help curb any misinformation that may arise
Peninsula Avenue Veterinary Clinic is committed to providing care for our patients during this COVID-19 crisis. We are working within the guidelines of the Centers for Disease Control (CDC), American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA), and the San Mateo Public Health Department to keep our hospital and staff free of the virus.
- Asking staff to stay home if they are sick or someone in their family is sick.
- Disinfecting all surfaces throughout the day, in particular door handles and front counters.
- Frequent hand washing
-Avoid touching our own faces
-Keeping a distance and discontinuing direct physical contacts such as handshaking or hugging.
In order to mitigate the spread of the virus we:
-Kindly request that you wait in the car or outside until we are ready for your appointment.
-Limit the family members attending the appointment to one person. We can use Facetime to include other family members.
-Do not enter the clinic if you are ill or have been exposed to someone that is ill. We can always meet you at the car to bring your pet inside and communicate via phone.
-Please wash your hands and cover any coughs.
Please be patient with us. We will be doing our best with frequent staff shortages and extra steps involved. We are here to help you and your family and want to do our best to mitigate the spread of this virus for the well being of all us and so we can resume our normal lives as soon as possible.
Staff at Peninsula Avenue Veterinary Clinic
Peninsula Avenue Veterinary Clinic is happy to announce our new online pharmacy!
Benefits of having an online pharmacy associated to the practice:
1. It's safer. Products are sent through a certified distributor.
2. Home delivery service with a focus on your pet's needs
3. Answering your demand for the convenience of home delivery.
4. 24/7 access to medications, prescriptions, and the entire line of Hill's Pet Nutrition products.
5. Making it easier than ever to follow treatment protocol with a customized reminder service and auto refill.
6. Reliable delivery to your front door. VetSource has fulfillment centers across the United States to provide quick, reliable delivery.
7. Easy as 1-2-3. You can quickly enroll at the hospital, online from home, or toll free at (877)738-4443.
8. Dedicated customer service support center with a toll-free number and extended hours.
With the beautiful weather, we hope you and your furry friend are out enjoying the sunshine. However, dogs can slip out of collars and cats can sneak through closing doors. It is estimated that 1 in 3 pets will go missing in their lifetime, and without permanent identification, 90% of those lost pets won’t return home. Microchipping gives your pet a permanent identification number that is registered to you, which increases the odds that you will be reunited you with your furry family member. This month, we are pleased to offer Microchipping for only $36.00 . Please call today to schedule an appointment for what may be a life-saving procedure!
Save This Life Microchips
We are Runners up on Beast of the Bay featured in the Bay Woof for Best Vet in Peninsula. What an amazing surprise! We are featured on Section 33d. Thank you all for the support!
Now that the rainy season is upon us, mosquito season is also here and lately we have been seeing a lot of mosquitoes in the area. It only takes one mosquito bite to allow the heartworm parasite to enter your dog or cat’s body, eventually maturing into long, thin worms that live and grow in your pet’s heart and surrounding blood vessels. Untreated, the disease leads to significant and deadly damage to the pet’s heart and lungs. The kidneys and liver can also be affected in some cases. We recommend year round heartworm prevention with yearly heartworm test in dogs. For cats, it is recommended they take heartworm prevention if they travel to one of the high risk states mentioned below. Cats have a very low risk in this area we live in.
Heartworm Prevention Awareness Month Special
April is designated for Heartworm Awareness. From now until April 30th 2016, we are offering 10% off when you buy a 6 month supply of Trifexis (flea and heartworm preventative) and $20 off the annual heartworm test (no exam required). The annual heartworm test is free when you purchase a 12 month supply of Trifexis along with the 10% off. Elanco also offers a rebate when you buy a 6 month or a 12 month supply of Trifexis.
*Offer is only valid to current clients that have had their pet examined within a year. Offer good though 04/30/2016.